Streamlining analysis methods for large acoustic surveys using automatic detectors with operator validation

• Published in: Methods in Ecology and Evolution
• Main Authors: Webber, Thomas, Gillespie, Douglas Michael, Lewis, Timothy, Gordon, Jonathan, Ruchirabha, Tararak, Thompson, Kirsten Freja
• Format: Article in Journal/Newspaper
• Language: English
• Published: 2022
• Subjects: Acoustic survey; Acoustics; Bioacoustics; Click train detector; Open-source; PAMGuard; Semi-automatic; Moan; Sperm whale; toothed whales
• Online Access: https://risweb.st-andrews.ac.uk/portal/en/researchoutput/streamlining-analysis-methods-for-large-acoustic-surveys-using-automatic-detectors-with-operator-validation(21ac5235-0539-423d-a0e4-bb9249f79fde).html; https://doi.org/10.1111/2041-210X.13907; https://research-repository.st-andrews.ac.uk/bitstream/10023/25541/1/Webber_2022_MEE_Streamlining_CC.pdf

1. Passive acoustic surveys are becoming increasingly popular as a means of surveying for cetaceans and other marine species. These surveys yield large amounts of data, the analysis of which is time consuming and can account for a substantial proportion of the survey budget. Semi-automatic processes enable the bulk of processing to be conducted automatically while allowing analyst time to be reserved for validating and correcting detections and classifications. 2. Existing modules within the Passive Acoustic Monitoring software PAMGuard were used to process a large (25.4 Terabyte) dataset collected during towed acoustic ship transits. The recently developed ‘Multi-Hypothesis Tracking Click Train Detector’ and the ‘Whistle and Moan Detector’ modules were used to identify occasions within the dataset at which vocalising toothed whales (odontocetes) were likely to be acoustically present. These putative detections were then reviewed by an analyst, with false positives being corrected. Target motion analysis provided a perpendicular distance to odontocete click events enabling the estimation of detection functions for both sperm whales and delphinids. Detected whistles were assigned to the lowest taxonomical level possible using the PAMGuard ‘Whistle Classifier’ module. 3. After an initial tuning process, this semi-automatic method required 91 hr of an analyst's time to manually review both automatic click train and whistle detections from 1,696 hr of survey data. Use of the ‘Multi-Hypothesis Tracking Click Train Detector’ reduced the amount of data for the analyst to search by 74.5%, while the ‘Whistle and Moan Detector’ reduced data to search by 85.9%. In total, 443 odontocete groups were detected, of which 55 were from sperm whale groups, six were from beaked whales, two were from porpoise and the remaining 380 were identified to the level of delphinid group. An effective survey strip half width of 3,277 and 699 m was estimated for sperm whales and delphinids respectively. 4. The semi-automatic workflow proved ...