Acoustic deterrent devices to prevent pinniped depredation:efficiency, conservation concerns and possible solutions

• Published in: Marine Ecology Progress Series
• Main Authors: Gotz, Thomas, Janik, Vincent M.
• Format: Article in Journal/Newspaper
• Language: English
• Published: 2013
• Subjects: Acoustic deterrent device; ADD; Noise pollution; Predation; Seal; Hearing damage; Aquaculture; Fisheries; Temporary threshold shift; Permanent threshold shift; toothed whales
• Online Access: https://research-portal.st-andrews.ac.uk/en/researchoutput/acoustic-deterrent-devices-to-prevent-pinniped-depredation(cc22e770-1f56-4fa5-80c0-e2b753ee5c1d).html; https://doi.org/10.3354/meps10482; https://research-repository.st-andrews.ac.uk/bitstream/10023/16356/1/goetz2013marineecologyseries285.pdf

Acoustic deterrent devices (ADDs) to prevent pinniped predation on fish farms and fisheries are widely used, but show highly varying success. Recently, ADDs have also been highlighted as a conservation concern due to their adverse impact on toothed whales. We review the available literature on the efficiency of commercial ADDs, evaluate the unintended impact on behaviour, communication and hearing of marine life, and suggest solutions based on psychophysiological predictions. The main problems associated with ADDs are a lack of long-term efficiency, introduction of substantial noise pollution to the marine environment and long-term effects on target and non-target species. Odontocetes have more sensitive hearing than pinnipeds at the frequencies where most ADDs operate, which may explain the reported large-scale habitat exclusion of odontocetes when ADDs are used. Furthermore, long-term exposure to ADDs may damage the hearing of marine mammals. Fish and invertebrates have less sensitive hearing than marine mammals and fewer efforts have been made to quantify the effects of noise on these taxa. Solutions can be found by decreasing sound exposure, exploiting neuronal reflex arcs associated with flight behaviour and making use of differences in species’ hearing abilities to increase target specificity. To minimise adverse effects, environmental impact assessments should be carried out before deploying ADDs and only effective and target-specific devices should be used.