On risk management of shipping system in ice-covered waters : Review, analysis and toolbox based on an eight-year polar project

With the climate change, polar sea ice is diminishing. This, on one hand, enables the possibility for e.g., Arctic shipping and relevant resource exploitation activities, but on the other hand brings additional risks induced by these activities. Increasing research focuses have been observed on the...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:Ocean Engineering
Main Authors: Lu, Liangliang, Kujala, Pentti, Kuikka, Sakari
Other Authors: Ecosystems and Environment Research Programme, Helsinki Institute of Sustainability Science (HELSUS), Biosciences, Fisheries and Environmental Management Group, Doctoral Programme in Wildlife Biology, Doctoral Programme in Interdisciplinary Environmental Sciences
Format: Review
Language:English
Published: PERGAMON 2023
Subjects:
Online Access:http://hdl.handle.net/10138/354865
id ftunivhelsihelda:oai:helda.helsinki.fi:10138/354865
record_format openpolar
institution Open Polar
collection HELDA – University of Helsinki Open Repository
op_collection_id ftunivhelsihelda
language English
topic Applicability
Ice-covered waters
Review and analysis
Risk management
Shipping system
Toolbox
1172 Environmental sciences
spellingShingle Applicability
Ice-covered waters
Review and analysis
Risk management
Shipping system
Toolbox
1172 Environmental sciences
Lu, Liangliang
Kujala, Pentti
Kuikka, Sakari
On risk management of shipping system in ice-covered waters : Review, analysis and toolbox based on an eight-year polar project
topic_facet Applicability
Ice-covered waters
Review and analysis
Risk management
Shipping system
Toolbox
1172 Environmental sciences
description With the climate change, polar sea ice is diminishing. This, on one hand, enables the possibility for e.g., Arctic shipping and relevant resource exploitation activities, but on the other hand brings additional risks induced by these activities. Increasing research focuses have been observed on the relevant topics in the complex and harsh polar environment and its fragile ecosystem. However, from risk management perspective, there is still a lack of holistic analysis and understanding towards safe shipping in the ice-covered waters and its available models applicable for managing risks in the system. Therefore, this paper aims to establish a framework and analysis for better understanding of this gap. The paper targets a comprehensive and long-term project specifically focusing on holistic safe shipping in ice-covered waters as the analysis basis. It firstly creates a holistic framework for the shipping system in ice-covered waters and then implements review and analysis of project publications on their overall features. Quantitative prediction models are selected for a structured applicability analysis. Furthermore, an extensive review outside the project following the elements established for the holistic shipping system is conducted so that this paper provides an overview of models for the shipping system in ice-covered waters, addressing the status of the current toolbox. Moreover, it helps to identify the next scientific steps on risk management of shipping in ice-covered waters. Peer reviewed
author2 Ecosystems and Environment Research Programme
Helsinki Institute of Sustainability Science (HELSUS)
Biosciences
Fisheries and Environmental Management Group
Doctoral Programme in Wildlife Biology
Doctoral Programme in Interdisciplinary Environmental Sciences
format Review
author Lu, Liangliang
Kujala, Pentti
Kuikka, Sakari
author_facet Lu, Liangliang
Kujala, Pentti
Kuikka, Sakari
author_sort Lu, Liangliang
title On risk management of shipping system in ice-covered waters : Review, analysis and toolbox based on an eight-year polar project
title_short On risk management of shipping system in ice-covered waters : Review, analysis and toolbox based on an eight-year polar project
title_full On risk management of shipping system in ice-covered waters : Review, analysis and toolbox based on an eight-year polar project
title_fullStr On risk management of shipping system in ice-covered waters : Review, analysis and toolbox based on an eight-year polar project
title_full_unstemmed On risk management of shipping system in ice-covered waters : Review, analysis and toolbox based on an eight-year polar project
title_sort on risk management of shipping system in ice-covered waters : review, analysis and toolbox based on an eight-year polar project
publisher PERGAMON
publishDate 2023
url http://hdl.handle.net/10138/354865
geographic Arctic
geographic_facet Arctic
genre Arctic
Arctic
Climate change
Sea ice
ice covered waters
genre_facet Arctic
Arctic
Climate change
Sea ice
ice covered waters
op_relation 10.1016/j.oceaneng.2022.113078
In order to have a holistic perspective and elements for the shipping system, the paper targets a comprehensive and long-term project specifically focusing on holistic safe polar shipping as the analysis basis. The long-term project has coherent focus and involves fundamental elements and holistic views towards safe polar shipping, thus provides a good basis for analysis. The polar project has two stages namely CEARCTIC (Centre of Excellence for Arctic Shipping and Operations) and CEPOLAR (Centre of Excellence for Scenario-based Risk Management in Polar Waters) starting from 2013 to 2022 focusing on different aspects regarding safe shipping in ice-covered waters. It is funded by Lloyd's Register Foundation and combines the research strengths from five universities: Aalto University, Hamburg University of Technology, Memorial University of Newfoundland, Norwegian University of Science and Technology and University of Helsinki. Extensive research work has been carried out in the framework of risk management towards safe shipping and the outcomes are mainly published in scientific journal and conference papers, where various subjects, research directions and methods have been focused and applied.Table 13 shows the toolbox under ecosystem impact topic. The model P3 adopts index-based approach to assess the vulnerability of Arctic biota. The resource and skill level needed are considered as medium and low respectively. The uncertainty is discussed to some extent; therefore, it is considered as a medium level SoE, which gives a M applicability level. The potential limitation is that the model still uses a number of judgements and uniform distribution due to lack of relevant data. In addition, the model does not include the spatial features for both oil spill and Arctic biota, which limits the practical utilization. The model P13 aims to estimate the probability of marine fish cell damages to oil spill. The required resource and skill level are low, and the model considers validation through a general comparison. Therefore, validation level is considered as Medium, and the final applicability level is rated as M as well. The limitation of the model is that the CPT states are limited and the modelling of structure and CPTs lack SoE supports.This project has received funding from the Lloyd's Register Foundation, a charitable foundation, helping to protect life and property by supporting engineering-related education, public engagement and the application of research www.lrfoundation.org.uk. This project has received funding from the Lloyd's Register Foundation , a charitable foundation, helping to protect life and property by supporting engineering-related education, public engagement and the application of research www.lrfoundation.org.uk .
Lu , L , Kujala , P & Kuikka , S 2022 , ' On risk management of shipping system in ice-covered waters : Review, analysis and toolbox based on an eight-year polar project ' , Ocean Engineering , vol. 266 , 113078 . https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oceaneng.2022.113078
ORCID: /0000-0001-8802-8013/work/129612368
85141788508
cd61361e-bf23-4671-b4c1-c1b5be7c3331
http://hdl.handle.net/10138/354865
op_rights cc_by
openAccess
info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
container_title Ocean Engineering
container_volume 266
container_start_page 113078
_version_ 1787421572104978432
spelling ftunivhelsihelda:oai:helda.helsinki.fi:10138/354865 2024-01-07T09:40:47+01:00 On risk management of shipping system in ice-covered waters : Review, analysis and toolbox based on an eight-year polar project Lu, Liangliang Kujala, Pentti Kuikka, Sakari Ecosystems and Environment Research Programme Helsinki Institute of Sustainability Science (HELSUS) Biosciences Fisheries and Environmental Management Group Doctoral Programme in Wildlife Biology Doctoral Programme in Interdisciplinary Environmental Sciences 2023-02-21T10:32:01Z application/pdf http://hdl.handle.net/10138/354865 eng eng PERGAMON 10.1016/j.oceaneng.2022.113078 In order to have a holistic perspective and elements for the shipping system, the paper targets a comprehensive and long-term project specifically focusing on holistic safe polar shipping as the analysis basis. The long-term project has coherent focus and involves fundamental elements and holistic views towards safe polar shipping, thus provides a good basis for analysis. The polar project has two stages namely CEARCTIC (Centre of Excellence for Arctic Shipping and Operations) and CEPOLAR (Centre of Excellence for Scenario-based Risk Management in Polar Waters) starting from 2013 to 2022 focusing on different aspects regarding safe shipping in ice-covered waters. It is funded by Lloyd's Register Foundation and combines the research strengths from five universities: Aalto University, Hamburg University of Technology, Memorial University of Newfoundland, Norwegian University of Science and Technology and University of Helsinki. Extensive research work has been carried out in the framework of risk management towards safe shipping and the outcomes are mainly published in scientific journal and conference papers, where various subjects, research directions and methods have been focused and applied.Table 13 shows the toolbox under ecosystem impact topic. The model P3 adopts index-based approach to assess the vulnerability of Arctic biota. The resource and skill level needed are considered as medium and low respectively. The uncertainty is discussed to some extent; therefore, it is considered as a medium level SoE, which gives a M applicability level. The potential limitation is that the model still uses a number of judgements and uniform distribution due to lack of relevant data. In addition, the model does not include the spatial features for both oil spill and Arctic biota, which limits the practical utilization. The model P13 aims to estimate the probability of marine fish cell damages to oil spill. The required resource and skill level are low, and the model considers validation through a general comparison. Therefore, validation level is considered as Medium, and the final applicability level is rated as M as well. The limitation of the model is that the CPT states are limited and the modelling of structure and CPTs lack SoE supports.This project has received funding from the Lloyd's Register Foundation, a charitable foundation, helping to protect life and property by supporting engineering-related education, public engagement and the application of research www.lrfoundation.org.uk. This project has received funding from the Lloyd's Register Foundation , a charitable foundation, helping to protect life and property by supporting engineering-related education, public engagement and the application of research www.lrfoundation.org.uk . Lu , L , Kujala , P & Kuikka , S 2022 , ' On risk management of shipping system in ice-covered waters : Review, analysis and toolbox based on an eight-year polar project ' , Ocean Engineering , vol. 266 , 113078 . https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oceaneng.2022.113078 ORCID: /0000-0001-8802-8013/work/129612368 85141788508 cd61361e-bf23-4671-b4c1-c1b5be7c3331 http://hdl.handle.net/10138/354865 cc_by openAccess info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess Applicability Ice-covered waters Review and analysis Risk management Shipping system Toolbox 1172 Environmental sciences Review Article publishedVersion 2023 ftunivhelsihelda 2023-12-14T00:07:06Z With the climate change, polar sea ice is diminishing. This, on one hand, enables the possibility for e.g., Arctic shipping and relevant resource exploitation activities, but on the other hand brings additional risks induced by these activities. Increasing research focuses have been observed on the relevant topics in the complex and harsh polar environment and its fragile ecosystem. However, from risk management perspective, there is still a lack of holistic analysis and understanding towards safe shipping in the ice-covered waters and its available models applicable for managing risks in the system. Therefore, this paper aims to establish a framework and analysis for better understanding of this gap. The paper targets a comprehensive and long-term project specifically focusing on holistic safe shipping in ice-covered waters as the analysis basis. It firstly creates a holistic framework for the shipping system in ice-covered waters and then implements review and analysis of project publications on their overall features. Quantitative prediction models are selected for a structured applicability analysis. Furthermore, an extensive review outside the project following the elements established for the holistic shipping system is conducted so that this paper provides an overview of models for the shipping system in ice-covered waters, addressing the status of the current toolbox. Moreover, it helps to identify the next scientific steps on risk management of shipping in ice-covered waters. Peer reviewed Review Arctic Arctic Climate change Sea ice ice covered waters HELDA – University of Helsinki Open Repository Arctic Ocean Engineering 266 113078