Erosion, Geological History, and Indigenous Agriculture: A Tale of Two Valleys

• Published in: Ecosystems
• Main Authors: Vitousek, PM, Chadwick, OA, Hilley, G, Kirch, PV, Ladefoged, TN
• Format: Article in Journal/Newspaper
• Language: English
• Published: Springer 2010
• Subjects: Science & Technology; Life Sciences & Biomedicine; Ecology; Environmental Sciences & Ecology; erosion; geomorphology; Hawai'i; human-environment interaction; intensive agriculture; irrigation; soil fertility; subsidence; weathering; HAWAIIAN-ISLANDS; VOLCANIC SOILS; LANDSCAPE; EVOLUTION; CHRONOLOGY; NUTRIENTS; CLIMATE; Young Island
• Online Access: http://hdl.handle.net/2292/20920; https://doi.org/10.1007/s10021-010-9354-1

Irrigated pondfields and rainfed field systems represented alternative pathways of agricultural intensification that were unevenly distributed across the Hawaiian Archipelago prior to European contact, with pondfields on wetter soils and older islands and rainfed systems on fertile, moderate-rainfall upland sites on younger islands. The spatial separation of these systems is thought to have contributed to the dynamics of social and political organization in pre-contact Hawai'i. However, deep stream valleys on older Hawaiian Islands often retain the remains of rainfed dryland agriculture on their lower slopes. We evaluated why rainfed agriculture developed on valley slopes on older but not younger islands by comparing soils of Pololū Valley on the young island of Hawai'i with those of Hālawa Valley on the older island of Moloka'i. Alluvial valley-bottom and colluvial slope soils of both valleys are enriched 4-5-fold in base saturation and in P that can be weathered, and greater than 10-fold in resin-extractable P and weatherable Ca, compared to soils of their surrounding uplands. However, due to an interaction of volcanically driven subsidence of the young island of Hawai'i with post-glacial sea level rise, the side walls of Pololū Valley plunge directly into a flat valley floor, whereas the alluvial floor of Hālawa Valley is surrounded by a band of fertile colluvial soils where rainfed agricultural features were concentrated. Only 5% of Pololū Valley supports colluvial soils with slopes between 5° and 12° (suitable for rainfed agriculture), whereas 16% of Hālawa Valley does so. The potential for integrated pondfield/rainfed valley systems of the older Hawaiian Islands increased their advantage in productivity and sustainability over the predominantly rainfed systems of the younger islands.