"Generality of mis-fit''?:The real-life difficulty of matching scales in an interconnected world

• Published in: Ambio
• Main Authors: Keskitalo, E. Carina H., Horstkotte, Tim, Kivinen, Sonja, Forbes, Bruce, Käyhkö, Jukka
• Format: Article in Journal/Newspaper
• Language: English
• Published: 2016
• Subjects: Goodness of fit; Scale; Mismatch; Reindeer husbandry; Fennoscandia; /dk/atira/pure/person/fieldofscience2010/1/18/1; name=Ecology; evolutionary biology; /dk/atira/pure/person/fieldofscience2010/5/17/1; name=Administrative science; /dk/atira/pure/person/fieldofscience2010/5/17/3; name=Political science; reindeer husbandry
• Online Access: https://research.ulapland.fi/fi/publications/329eb875-8a5a-464e-a97f-9fe35ac1a71d; https://doi.org/10.1007/s13280-015-0757-2

A clear understanding of processes at multiple scales and levels is of special significance when conceiving strategies for human--environment interactions. However, understanding and application of the scale concept often differ between administrative-political and ecological disciplines. These mirror major differences in potential solutions whether and how scales can, at all, be made congruent. As a result, opportunities of seeking "goodness-of-fit'' between different concepts of governance should perhaps be reconsidered in the light of a potential "generality of mis-fit.'' This article reviews the interdisciplinary considerations inherent in the concept of scale in its ecological, as well as administrative-political, significance and argues that issues of how to manage "mis-fit'' should be awarded more emphasis in social-ecological research and management practices. These considerations are exemplified by the case of reindeer husbandry in Fennoscandia. Whilst an indigenous small-scale practice, reindeer husbandry involves multi-level ecological and administrative-political complexities---complexities that we argue may arise in any multi-level system.