Regional och global syn på hällrustningar
SUMMARY In a review article on P. V. Glob's recent publication, »Rock Carvings in Denmark«, the author compares the situation in Scandinavian petroglyph studies today with that in 1945 when C. A. Althin published his monograph on the petroglyphs of Scania -mainly those within sight of the sites...
Main Author: | |
---|---|
Format: | Article in Journal/Newspaper |
Language: | Danish |
Published: |
Jysk Arkæologisk Selskab
1970
|
Subjects: | |
Online Access: | https://tidsskrift.dk/kuml/article/view/105427 |
id |
ftsbaarhusojs:oai:ojs.tidsskrift.dk:article/105427 |
---|---|
record_format |
openpolar |
spelling |
ftsbaarhusojs:oai:ojs.tidsskrift.dk:article/105427 2023-05-15T15:10:56+02:00 Regional och global syn på hällrustningar Moberg, C. A. 1970-04-24 application/pdf https://tidsskrift.dk/kuml/article/view/105427 dan dan Jysk Arkæologisk Selskab https://tidsskrift.dk/kuml/article/view/105427/154231 https://tidsskrift.dk/kuml/article/view/105427 Kuml; Årg. 20 Nr. 20 (1970); 223-232 Kuml; Vol. 20 No. 20 (1970); 223-232 2446-3280 0454-6245 petroglyph billedsten research comparison forskningssammenligning glob binford info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion 1970 ftsbaarhusojs 2021-05-06T20:33:12Z SUMMARY In a review article on P. V. Glob's recent publication, »Rock Carvings in Denmark«, the author compares the situation in Scandinavian petroglyph studies today with that in 1945 when C. A. Althin published his monograph on the petroglyphs of Scania -mainly those within sight of the sites on the island of Bornholm, a main theme in Glob's book. We are still far from relieved of the necessity to accept isolated »petroglyph research« - with all the dangers of speculation and sterility involved. There is still too little chronology, and too few contextual data for the petroglyphs. In a cross-regional argument, the view preferred here is that the dichotomy between »South Scandinavian«, »bronze age«, »agricultural« petroglyphs and »Arctic«, »North Scandinavian«, »hunting and fishing« petroglyphs has been overemphasized. None of the quoted labels are adequate today. The first mentioned group (the »shiptype« rock art) is seen as a south-western, geographically marginal part of a large North and East European, partly North Asiatic complex, together with the »gametype« art, which prevails towards the north-east.In Lewis R. Binford's »Archeological Perspectives«, questions of the importance or non-importance of »hidden data« are discussed -with a passage in B. Allchin's »The stone-tipped arrow« as an example. It is clear that Glob's analogous way of reasoning would be refuted by Binford. On the other hand, the consequence of Binford's position would be to emphasize the importance of studies of »independent« data, parallel with the petroglyph study. In fact, Glob has a marked tendency in this sound direction.C. A. Moberg Article in Journal/Newspaper Arctic Aarhus University: OJS at The State and University Library Arctic Moberg ENVELOPE(20.782,20.782,69.518,69.518) |
institution |
Open Polar |
collection |
Aarhus University: OJS at The State and University Library |
op_collection_id |
ftsbaarhusojs |
language |
Danish |
topic |
petroglyph billedsten research comparison forskningssammenligning glob binford |
spellingShingle |
petroglyph billedsten research comparison forskningssammenligning glob binford Moberg, C. A. Regional och global syn på hällrustningar |
topic_facet |
petroglyph billedsten research comparison forskningssammenligning glob binford |
description |
SUMMARY In a review article on P. V. Glob's recent publication, »Rock Carvings in Denmark«, the author compares the situation in Scandinavian petroglyph studies today with that in 1945 when C. A. Althin published his monograph on the petroglyphs of Scania -mainly those within sight of the sites on the island of Bornholm, a main theme in Glob's book. We are still far from relieved of the necessity to accept isolated »petroglyph research« - with all the dangers of speculation and sterility involved. There is still too little chronology, and too few contextual data for the petroglyphs. In a cross-regional argument, the view preferred here is that the dichotomy between »South Scandinavian«, »bronze age«, »agricultural« petroglyphs and »Arctic«, »North Scandinavian«, »hunting and fishing« petroglyphs has been overemphasized. None of the quoted labels are adequate today. The first mentioned group (the »shiptype« rock art) is seen as a south-western, geographically marginal part of a large North and East European, partly North Asiatic complex, together with the »gametype« art, which prevails towards the north-east.In Lewis R. Binford's »Archeological Perspectives«, questions of the importance or non-importance of »hidden data« are discussed -with a passage in B. Allchin's »The stone-tipped arrow« as an example. It is clear that Glob's analogous way of reasoning would be refuted by Binford. On the other hand, the consequence of Binford's position would be to emphasize the importance of studies of »independent« data, parallel with the petroglyph study. In fact, Glob has a marked tendency in this sound direction.C. A. Moberg |
format |
Article in Journal/Newspaper |
author |
Moberg, C. A. |
author_facet |
Moberg, C. A. |
author_sort |
Moberg, C. A. |
title |
Regional och global syn på hällrustningar |
title_short |
Regional och global syn på hällrustningar |
title_full |
Regional och global syn på hällrustningar |
title_fullStr |
Regional och global syn på hällrustningar |
title_full_unstemmed |
Regional och global syn på hällrustningar |
title_sort |
regional och global syn på hällrustningar |
publisher |
Jysk Arkæologisk Selskab |
publishDate |
1970 |
url |
https://tidsskrift.dk/kuml/article/view/105427 |
long_lat |
ENVELOPE(20.782,20.782,69.518,69.518) |
geographic |
Arctic Moberg |
geographic_facet |
Arctic Moberg |
genre |
Arctic |
genre_facet |
Arctic |
op_source |
Kuml; Årg. 20 Nr. 20 (1970); 223-232 Kuml; Vol. 20 No. 20 (1970); 223-232 2446-3280 0454-6245 |
op_relation |
https://tidsskrift.dk/kuml/article/view/105427/154231 https://tidsskrift.dk/kuml/article/view/105427 |
_version_ |
1766341869987430400 |