Personality Profiles and the Russian Soul: Literary and Scholarly Views Evaluated

Many domestic and foreign observers have claimed that Russians have a unique constellation of personality traits that mirrors their distinctive historical and cultural experience. To examine the hypothesized uniqueness of Russian personality, members of the Russian Character and Personality Survey c...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology
Main Authors: Allik, J., Realo, A., Mottus, R., Pullmann, H., Trifonova, A., McCrae, R. R., Yurina, A. A., Shebanets, E. Y., Fadina, A. G., Tikhonova, E. V., Troitskaya, I. Y., Fatyhova, R. M., Petrova, I. F., Tudupova, T. T., Tsiring, D. A., Panfilov, A. N., L'dokova, G. M., Aristova, I. L., Mescheryakov, B. G., Zorina, J., Yuschenkova, D. V., Fotekova, T. A., Osmina, E. V., Vavilkina, N. G., Skhorohodova, N. Y., Zernova, T. I., Dostovalov, S. G., Kadykova, S. A., Korepanova, I. A., Saharova, A., Naumov, N. D., Snegireva, T. V., Kuznetsov, I. Y., Kuznetsova, S. A., Rubtsova, M. O., Filatova, A. F., Nechaeva, T. M., Borisova, S. N., Postnikova, M. I., Gluhanyuk, N. S., Dyachenko, E. V., Fomina, N. A., Eromasova, A. A., Myshkina, S. V., Rulina, T. K., Yavkina, E. V., Knyazev, G. G., Ryabichenko, T. I., Demidova, I. F., Uvarov, E. A., Lopukhova, O. G., Vasyagina, N. N., Leonenko, N. O., Arinin, E. I., Lyapina, A. A., Dulina, N. V., Poyarova, T. A., Gaidar, K. M., Baranov, A. A., Kozhevnikova, O. V., Kalinichenko, O. V., Korneeva, E .E.
Format: Article in Journal/Newspaper
Language:English
Published: Sage Publications Inc 2023
Subjects:
Online Access:https://elar.rsvpu.ru/handle/123456789/42419
https://doi.org/10.1177/0022022110362751
id ftrsvpuniv:oai:elar.rsvpu.ru:123456789/42419
record_format openpolar
institution Open Polar
collection Russian State Vocational Pedagogical University (RSVPU), Jekaterinburg: Electronic Archive
op_collection_id ftrsvpuniv
language English
topic PERSONALITY
RUSSIAN SOUL
RUSSIAN NATIONAL CHARACTER: NEO PI-R
BIG FIVE
CROSS-CULTURAL COMPARISON
PERSONALITY RATINGS
NATIONAL CHARACTER
STEREOTYPE
RELIGION
spellingShingle PERSONALITY
RUSSIAN SOUL
RUSSIAN NATIONAL CHARACTER: NEO PI-R
BIG FIVE
CROSS-CULTURAL COMPARISON
PERSONALITY RATINGS
NATIONAL CHARACTER
STEREOTYPE
RELIGION
Allik, J.
Realo, A.
Mottus, R.
Pullmann, H.
Trifonova, A.
McCrae, R. R.
Yurina, A. A.
Shebanets, E. Y.
Fadina, A. G.
Tikhonova, E. V.
Troitskaya, I. Y.
Fatyhova, R. M.
Petrova, I. F.
Tudupova, T. T.
Tsiring, D. A.
Panfilov, A. N.
L'dokova, G. M.
Aristova, I. L.
Mescheryakov, B. G.
Zorina, J.
Yuschenkova, D. V.
Fotekova, T. A.
Osmina, E. V.
Vavilkina, N. G.
Skhorohodova, N. Y.
Zernova, T. I.
Dostovalov, S. G.
Kadykova, S. A.
Korepanova, I. A.
Saharova, A.
Naumov, N. D.
Snegireva, T. V.
Kuznetsov, I. Y.
Kuznetsova, S. A.
Rubtsova, M. O.
Filatova, A. F.
Nechaeva, T. M.
Borisova, S. N.
Postnikova, M. I.
Gluhanyuk, N. S.
Dyachenko, E. V.
Fomina, N. A.
Eromasova, A. A.
Myshkina, S. V.
Rulina, T. K.
Yavkina, E. V.
Knyazev, G. G.
Ryabichenko, T. I.
Demidova, I. F.
Uvarov, E. A.
Lopukhova, O. G.
Vasyagina, N. N.
Leonenko, N. O.
Arinin, E. I.
Lyapina, A. A.
Dulina, N. V.
Poyarova, T. A.
Gaidar, K. M.
Baranov, A. A.
Kozhevnikova, O. V.
Kalinichenko, O. V.
Korneeva, E .E.
Personality Profiles and the Russian Soul: Literary and Scholarly Views Evaluated
topic_facet PERSONALITY
RUSSIAN SOUL
RUSSIAN NATIONAL CHARACTER: NEO PI-R
BIG FIVE
CROSS-CULTURAL COMPARISON
PERSONALITY RATINGS
NATIONAL CHARACTER
STEREOTYPE
RELIGION
description Many domestic and foreign observers have claimed that Russians have a unique constellation of personality traits that mirrors their distinctive historical and cultural experience. To examine the hypothesized uniqueness of Russian personality, members of the Russian Character and Personality Survey collected data from 39 samples in 33 administrative areas of the Russian Federation. Respondents (N = 7,065) identified an ethnically Russian adult or college-aged man or woman whom they knew well and rated the target using the Russian observer-rating version of the Revised NEO Personality Inventory. The mean personality profile of Russians was very similar to the international average based on 50 different countries, debunking the myth of a unique Russian soul. The small variations from world norms did not converge with depictions of Russian national character in fiction and the scholarly literature. New items intended to capture distinctive, emic aspects of Russian personality provided no new information beyond the familiar Big Five dimensions. Religion, ethnicity, and beliefs about the uniqueness of the Russian character and the malleability of personality traits had little effect on personality ratings. Perceptions of the Russian soul do not seem to be based on the personality traits of Russians.
format Article in Journal/Newspaper
author Allik, J.
Realo, A.
Mottus, R.
Pullmann, H.
Trifonova, A.
McCrae, R. R.
Yurina, A. A.
Shebanets, E. Y.
Fadina, A. G.
Tikhonova, E. V.
Troitskaya, I. Y.
Fatyhova, R. M.
Petrova, I. F.
Tudupova, T. T.
Tsiring, D. A.
Panfilov, A. N.
L'dokova, G. M.
Aristova, I. L.
Mescheryakov, B. G.
Zorina, J.
Yuschenkova, D. V.
Fotekova, T. A.
Osmina, E. V.
Vavilkina, N. G.
Skhorohodova, N. Y.
Zernova, T. I.
Dostovalov, S. G.
Kadykova, S. A.
Korepanova, I. A.
Saharova, A.
Naumov, N. D.
Snegireva, T. V.
Kuznetsov, I. Y.
Kuznetsova, S. A.
Rubtsova, M. O.
Filatova, A. F.
Nechaeva, T. M.
Borisova, S. N.
Postnikova, M. I.
Gluhanyuk, N. S.
Dyachenko, E. V.
Fomina, N. A.
Eromasova, A. A.
Myshkina, S. V.
Rulina, T. K.
Yavkina, E. V.
Knyazev, G. G.
Ryabichenko, T. I.
Demidova, I. F.
Uvarov, E. A.
Lopukhova, O. G.
Vasyagina, N. N.
Leonenko, N. O.
Arinin, E. I.
Lyapina, A. A.
Dulina, N. V.
Poyarova, T. A.
Gaidar, K. M.
Baranov, A. A.
Kozhevnikova, O. V.
Kalinichenko, O. V.
Korneeva, E .E.
author_facet Allik, J.
Realo, A.
Mottus, R.
Pullmann, H.
Trifonova, A.
McCrae, R. R.
Yurina, A. A.
Shebanets, E. Y.
Fadina, A. G.
Tikhonova, E. V.
Troitskaya, I. Y.
Fatyhova, R. M.
Petrova, I. F.
Tudupova, T. T.
Tsiring, D. A.
Panfilov, A. N.
L'dokova, G. M.
Aristova, I. L.
Mescheryakov, B. G.
Zorina, J.
Yuschenkova, D. V.
Fotekova, T. A.
Osmina, E. V.
Vavilkina, N. G.
Skhorohodova, N. Y.
Zernova, T. I.
Dostovalov, S. G.
Kadykova, S. A.
Korepanova, I. A.
Saharova, A.
Naumov, N. D.
Snegireva, T. V.
Kuznetsov, I. Y.
Kuznetsova, S. A.
Rubtsova, M. O.
Filatova, A. F.
Nechaeva, T. M.
Borisova, S. N.
Postnikova, M. I.
Gluhanyuk, N. S.
Dyachenko, E. V.
Fomina, N. A.
Eromasova, A. A.
Myshkina, S. V.
Rulina, T. K.
Yavkina, E. V.
Knyazev, G. G.
Ryabichenko, T. I.
Demidova, I. F.
Uvarov, E. A.
Lopukhova, O. G.
Vasyagina, N. N.
Leonenko, N. O.
Arinin, E. I.
Lyapina, A. A.
Dulina, N. V.
Poyarova, T. A.
Gaidar, K. M.
Baranov, A. A.
Kozhevnikova, O. V.
Kalinichenko, O. V.
Korneeva, E .E.
author_sort Allik, J.
title Personality Profiles and the Russian Soul: Literary and Scholarly Views Evaluated
title_short Personality Profiles and the Russian Soul: Literary and Scholarly Views Evaluated
title_full Personality Profiles and the Russian Soul: Literary and Scholarly Views Evaluated
title_fullStr Personality Profiles and the Russian Soul: Literary and Scholarly Views Evaluated
title_full_unstemmed Personality Profiles and the Russian Soul: Literary and Scholarly Views Evaluated
title_sort personality profiles and the russian soul: literary and scholarly views evaluated
publisher Sage Publications Inc
publishDate 2023
url https://elar.rsvpu.ru/handle/123456789/42419
https://doi.org/10.1177/0022022110362751
op_coverage RSVPU
WOS
genre Arctic
genre_facet Arctic
op_source Journal Of Cross-Cultural Psychology
op_relation 0022-0221
1552-5422
https://elar.rsvpu.ru/handle/123456789/42419
doi:10.1177/0022022110362751
79953215285
2-s2.0-79953215285
University of Tartu; National Institutes of Health (NIH) - USA; NIH National Institute on Aging (NIA); Adyghe State University; Astrakhan State University; Bashkir State Pedagogical University; Buryat State University; Chelyabinsk State University; Kazan Federal University; Far Eastern Federal University; Dubna State University; Katanov Khakass State University; Kalashnikov Izhevsk State Technical University; Kurgan State University; Mari State University; Moscow State University of Psychology & Education; North-Eastern Federal University in Yakutsk; Novosibirsk State Pedagogical University; Omsk State Pedagogical University; Orel State University; Perm State University; Northern Arctic Federal University; Russian State Vocational Pedagogical University; Samara State University of Social Sciences & Education; Russian Academy of Sciences; Derzhavin Tambov State University; Kazan Federal University; Ural State Pedagogical University; Vladimir State University; Volgograd State Technical University; Voronezh State University; Udmurt State University; Yaroslavl State University; Vologda State University
WOS
WOS:000288849200004
000288849200004
op_rights info:eu-repo/semantics/restrictedAccess
op_doi https://doi.org/10.1177/0022022110362751
container_title Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology
container_volume 42
container_issue 3
container_start_page 372
op_container_end_page 389
_version_ 1789961211691925504
spelling ftrsvpuniv:oai:elar.rsvpu.ru:123456789/42419 2024-02-04T09:56:52+01:00 Personality Profiles and the Russian Soul: Literary and Scholarly Views Evaluated Allik, J. Realo, A. Mottus, R. Pullmann, H. Trifonova, A. McCrae, R. R. Yurina, A. A. Shebanets, E. Y. Fadina, A. G. Tikhonova, E. V. Troitskaya, I. Y. Fatyhova, R. M. Petrova, I. F. Tudupova, T. T. Tsiring, D. A. Panfilov, A. N. L'dokova, G. M. Aristova, I. L. Mescheryakov, B. G. Zorina, J. Yuschenkova, D. V. Fotekova, T. A. Osmina, E. V. Vavilkina, N. G. Skhorohodova, N. Y. Zernova, T. I. Dostovalov, S. G. Kadykova, S. A. Korepanova, I. A. Saharova, A. Naumov, N. D. Snegireva, T. V. Kuznetsov, I. Y. Kuznetsova, S. A. Rubtsova, M. O. Filatova, A. F. Nechaeva, T. M. Borisova, S. N. Postnikova, M. I. Gluhanyuk, N. S. Dyachenko, E. V. Fomina, N. A. Eromasova, A. A. Myshkina, S. V. Rulina, T. K. Yavkina, E. V. Knyazev, G. G. Ryabichenko, T. I. Demidova, I. F. Uvarov, E. A. Lopukhova, O. G. Vasyagina, N. N. Leonenko, N. O. Arinin, E. I. Lyapina, A. A. Dulina, N. V. Poyarova, T. A. Gaidar, K. M. Baranov, A. A. Kozhevnikova, O. V. Kalinichenko, O. V. Korneeva, E .E. RSVPU WOS 2023-04-29T14:59:46Z https://elar.rsvpu.ru/handle/123456789/42419 https://doi.org/10.1177/0022022110362751 en eng Sage Publications Inc 0022-0221 1552-5422 https://elar.rsvpu.ru/handle/123456789/42419 doi:10.1177/0022022110362751 79953215285 2-s2.0-79953215285 University of Tartu; National Institutes of Health (NIH) - USA; NIH National Institute on Aging (NIA); Adyghe State University; Astrakhan State University; Bashkir State Pedagogical University; Buryat State University; Chelyabinsk State University; Kazan Federal University; Far Eastern Federal University; Dubna State University; Katanov Khakass State University; Kalashnikov Izhevsk State Technical University; Kurgan State University; Mari State University; Moscow State University of Psychology & Education; North-Eastern Federal University in Yakutsk; Novosibirsk State Pedagogical University; Omsk State Pedagogical University; Orel State University; Perm State University; Northern Arctic Federal University; Russian State Vocational Pedagogical University; Samara State University of Social Sciences & Education; Russian Academy of Sciences; Derzhavin Tambov State University; Kazan Federal University; Ural State Pedagogical University; Vladimir State University; Volgograd State Technical University; Voronezh State University; Udmurt State University; Yaroslavl State University; Vologda State University WOS WOS:000288849200004 000288849200004 info:eu-repo/semantics/restrictedAccess Journal Of Cross-Cultural Psychology PERSONALITY RUSSIAN SOUL RUSSIAN NATIONAL CHARACTER: NEO PI-R BIG FIVE CROSS-CULTURAL COMPARISON PERSONALITY RATINGS NATIONAL CHARACTER STEREOTYPE RELIGION Article info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion 2023 ftrsvpuniv https://doi.org/10.1177/0022022110362751 2024-01-09T01:18:08Z Many domestic and foreign observers have claimed that Russians have a unique constellation of personality traits that mirrors their distinctive historical and cultural experience. To examine the hypothesized uniqueness of Russian personality, members of the Russian Character and Personality Survey collected data from 39 samples in 33 administrative areas of the Russian Federation. Respondents (N = 7,065) identified an ethnically Russian adult or college-aged man or woman whom they knew well and rated the target using the Russian observer-rating version of the Revised NEO Personality Inventory. The mean personality profile of Russians was very similar to the international average based on 50 different countries, debunking the myth of a unique Russian soul. The small variations from world norms did not converge with depictions of Russian national character in fiction and the scholarly literature. New items intended to capture distinctive, emic aspects of Russian personality provided no new information beyond the familiar Big Five dimensions. Religion, ethnicity, and beliefs about the uniqueness of the Russian character and the malleability of personality traits had little effect on personality ratings. Perceptions of the Russian soul do not seem to be based on the personality traits of Russians. Article in Journal/Newspaper Arctic Russian State Vocational Pedagogical University (RSVPU), Jekaterinburg: Electronic Archive Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 42 3 372 389