Growth, Transition, and Decline in Resource Based Socio-Ecological Systems

• Main Author: Brooks A. Kaiser
• Format: Report
• Language: unknown
• Subjects: Arctic; Arctic Fox; bowhead whale; inuit; walrus*
• Online Access: http://www.sdu.dk/~/media/Files/Om_SDU/Institutter/Miljo/ime/wp/kaiser319.ashx

Globalization transforms communities. Increased trade and technology can disrupt existing socio-ecological systems that may have persisted for hundreds or thousands of years. Whole socio-ecological systems may be destroyed or subsumed into a new dominant culture, as has occurred with many Indigenous cultures worldwide. In this context, I examine the Thule Inuit culture as a dynamic and multi-trophic socio-ecological system. Lessons from the study clarify fundamentals of trade and development: mutual benefits from trade rely upon equitable terms that sustain the original stewards of the ecological resource base; the ability to achieve such equitable terms is a function of governance mechanisms and capabilities; and the need for such institutional tools and governance mechanisms should be internally as well as externally recognized for all trading parties. The multi-trophic model includes three layers: a composite ecosystem resource base, a resource-dependent human population, and a top trophic human group of Traditional Ecological Knowledge (TEK) holders connected through caloric productivity and use. I calibrate the model with what can be known or deduced from the historical record and ecological evidence. I examine how new stressors to the Thule Inuit system, including the foreign commercial whaling and fur trading that brought particularly rapid shifts from the 1820s forward, transformed the system dynamics. Differences in the ways in which the two commercial enterprises evolved across Inuit communities, particularly in terms of net changes in access to calories and new technologies, provide comparative insights into how socio-ecological systems can gain or lose as the introduction of trade and technology can shift relative rates of return amongst ecosystem components. Thule Inuit, Traditional Ecological Knowledge (TEK), socio-ecological systems, whaling industry, technological change in socio-ecological systems, dynamics of globalization, ecosystem-based trade, Arctic fox, Arctic economic development, fur trade, bowhead whale, walrus