Ocean Acidification and the End-Permian Mass Extinction: To What Extent does Evidence Support Hypothesis?

• Published in: Geosciences
• Main Authors: Stephen Kershaw, Sylvie Crasquin, Yue Li, Pierre-Yves Collin, Marie-Béatrice Forel
• Format: Text
• Language: English
• Published: Molecular Diversity Preservation International 2012
• Subjects: ocean acidification; end-Permian extinction; microbialite; ocean buffer; stylolite; Ocean acidification
• Online Access: https://doi.org/10.3390/geosciences2040221

Ocean acidification in modern oceans is linked to rapid increase in atmospheric CO2, raising concern about marine diversity, food security and ecosystem services. Proxy evidence for acidification during past crises may help predict future change, but three issues limit confidence of comparisons between modern and ancient ocean acidification, illustrated from the end-Permian extinction, 252 million years ago: (1) problems with evidence for ocean acidification preserved in sedimentary rocks, where proposed marine dissolution surfaces may be subaerial. Sedimentary evidence that the extinction was partly due to ocean acidification is therefore inconclusive; (2) Fossils of marine animals potentially affected by ocean acidification are imperfect records of past conditions; selective extinction of hypercalcifying organisms is uncertain evidence for acidification; (3) The current high rates of acidification may not reflect past rates, which cannot be measured directly, and whose temporal resolution decreases in older rocks. Thus large increases in CO2 in the past may have occurred over a long enough time to have allowed assimilation into the oceans, and acidification may not have stressed ocean biota to the present extent. Although we acknowledge the very likely occurrence of past ocean acidification, obtaining support presents a continuing challenge for the Earth science community.