Some honest talk about Non-Indigenous Education
Euro-Canadians try and play it both ways when we use the word “education.” On the one hand we claim open-mindedness by asserting platitudes like ‘all societies have education’ — including Indigenous societies. And on the other hand, we then frequently refer to Indigenous people as “uneducated”--casu...
Main Author: | |
---|---|
Language: | English |
Published: |
Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (CCPA)
2011
|
Subjects: | |
Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.17613/hdy5-0h46 |
_version_ | 1821560612388339712 |
---|---|
author | Derek Rasmussen |
author_facet | Derek Rasmussen |
author_sort | Derek Rasmussen |
collection | Humanities Commons CORE Deposits |
description | Euro-Canadians try and play it both ways when we use the word “education.” On the one hand we claim open-mindedness by asserting platitudes like ‘all societies have education’ — including Indigenous societies. And on the other hand, we then frequently refer to Indigenous people as “uneducated”--casually denigrating them because they weren’t admitted into or didn’t graduate out of the deliberately narrow funnel we've invented: European institutional education. This can be termed the “Restaurant Theory of Education”, wherein we think of the relationship between Education (scarce) and cultural trans-mission (wide) as being like the relationship between restaurants and food. Restaurants can be found in most Euro-Canadian neighborhoods—as can schools—butt we don't believe that without restaurants we would starve. If we come across a society without schools, then we assume that there has to be some sort of Education system hidden in the social structure somewhere and we just have to suss it out. Yet if we don’t see restaurants in another civilization we don’t immediately assume that they must have a restaurant system hidden in their food relations somewhere. |
genre | inuit |
genre_facet | inuit |
id | fthcommons:oai:hcommons.org/hc:61091 |
institution | Open Polar |
language | English |
op_collection_id | fthcommons |
op_doi | https://doi.org/10.17613/hdy5-0h46 |
publishDate | 2011 |
publisher | Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (CCPA) |
record_format | openpolar |
spelling | fthcommons:oai:hcommons.org/hc:61091 2025-01-16T22:43:58+00:00 Some honest talk about Non-Indigenous Education Derek Rasmussen 2011 https://doi.org/10.17613/hdy5-0h46 English eng Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (CCPA) 1356990:Great transformation (Polanyi Karl):Uniform Title 2058748:Deschooling society (Illich Ivan):Uniform Title 977874:Inuit--Education:Topic 970231:Indigenous peoples--European colonies:Topic 970228:Indigenous peoples--Education:Topic 1737534:Racism in education:Topic 1287524:Nunavut:Geographic 902835:Education and state:Topic 1496:Scott James C.:Personal Name 2011 fthcommons https://doi.org/10.17613/hdy5-0h46 2024-10-22T01:07:10Z Euro-Canadians try and play it both ways when we use the word “education.” On the one hand we claim open-mindedness by asserting platitudes like ‘all societies have education’ — including Indigenous societies. And on the other hand, we then frequently refer to Indigenous people as “uneducated”--casually denigrating them because they weren’t admitted into or didn’t graduate out of the deliberately narrow funnel we've invented: European institutional education. This can be termed the “Restaurant Theory of Education”, wherein we think of the relationship between Education (scarce) and cultural trans-mission (wide) as being like the relationship between restaurants and food. Restaurants can be found in most Euro-Canadian neighborhoods—as can schools—butt we don't believe that without restaurants we would starve. If we come across a society without schools, then we assume that there has to be some sort of Education system hidden in the social structure somewhere and we just have to suss it out. Yet if we don’t see restaurants in another civilization we don’t immediately assume that they must have a restaurant system hidden in their food relations somewhere. Other/Unknown Material inuit Humanities Commons CORE Deposits |
spellingShingle | 1356990:Great transformation (Polanyi Karl):Uniform Title 2058748:Deschooling society (Illich Ivan):Uniform Title 977874:Inuit--Education:Topic 970231:Indigenous peoples--European colonies:Topic 970228:Indigenous peoples--Education:Topic 1737534:Racism in education:Topic 1287524:Nunavut:Geographic 902835:Education and state:Topic 1496:Scott James C.:Personal Name Derek Rasmussen Some honest talk about Non-Indigenous Education |
title | Some honest talk about Non-Indigenous Education |
title_full | Some honest talk about Non-Indigenous Education |
title_fullStr | Some honest talk about Non-Indigenous Education |
title_full_unstemmed | Some honest talk about Non-Indigenous Education |
title_short | Some honest talk about Non-Indigenous Education |
title_sort | some honest talk about non-indigenous education |
topic | 1356990:Great transformation (Polanyi Karl):Uniform Title 2058748:Deschooling society (Illich Ivan):Uniform Title 977874:Inuit--Education:Topic 970231:Indigenous peoples--European colonies:Topic 970228:Indigenous peoples--Education:Topic 1737534:Racism in education:Topic 1287524:Nunavut:Geographic 902835:Education and state:Topic 1496:Scott James C.:Personal Name |
topic_facet | 1356990:Great transformation (Polanyi Karl):Uniform Title 2058748:Deschooling society (Illich Ivan):Uniform Title 977874:Inuit--Education:Topic 970231:Indigenous peoples--European colonies:Topic 970228:Indigenous peoples--Education:Topic 1737534:Racism in education:Topic 1287524:Nunavut:Geographic 902835:Education and state:Topic 1496:Scott James C.:Personal Name |
url | https://doi.org/10.17613/hdy5-0h46 |