The ecological success of river restoration in Newfoundland and Labrador, Canada: lessons learned

• Published in: Ecology and Society
• Main Authors: Skylar W Skinner, Anastasia Addai, Stephen E. Decker, Michael van Zyll de Jong
• Format: Article in Journal/Newspaper
• Language: English
• Published: Resilience Alliance 2023
• Subjects: canada; database; ecological; evaluation; monitoring; planning; river restoration; Biology (General); QH301-705.5; Ecology; QH540-549.5; Canada; Newfoundland
• Online Access: https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-14379-280320; https://doaj.org/article/ca34415daa0d40c8aca735c9cf6ed534

Despite millions of dollars being spent annually to restore degraded river ecosystems, there exist relatively few assessments of the ecological effectiveness of projects. An evidence-based synthesis was conducted to describe river restoration activities in Newfoundland and Labrador. The synthesis identified 170 river restoration projects between 1949 and 2020. A practitioner’s survey was conducted on a subset of 91 projects to evaluate ecological success. When the perceived success of managers was compared to an independent assessment of ecological success, 82% of respondents believe the projects to be completely or somewhat successful whereas only 41% of projects were evaluated as ecologically successful through an independent assessment. Only 11% of practitioners’ evaluations used ecological indicators, yet managers of 66% of projects reported improvements in river ecosystems. This contradiction reveals a lack of the application of evidence to support value-based judgments by practitioners. Despite reporting that monitoring data were used in the assessment it is doubtful that any meaningful ecological assessment was conducted. If we are to improve the science of river restoration, projects must demonstrate evidence of ecological success to qualify as sound restoration. River restoration is a necessary tool to ensure the sustainability of river ecosystems. The assessment conducted in this study suggests that our approach to planning, designing, implementing, monitoring, and evaluating projects needs to improve. An integrated-systems view that gives attention to stakeholders’ values and scientific information concerning the potential consequences of alternative restoration actions on key ecosystem indicators is required.