Sub-ethnic groups of the Tuvans : problems of definition and research

• Main Author: Chimiza K. Lamazhaa
• Format: Article in Journal/Newspaper
• Language: Russian
• Published: Novye Issledovaniâ Tuvy 2017
• Subjects: субэтнические группы; субэтнические группы тувинцев; этнолокальные группы; усинские тувинцы; тувинцы Монголии; тувинцы Китая; тувинцы-тоджинцы; этнографические термины; Communities. Classes. Races; HT51-1595; Usinsk
• Online Access: https://doaj.org/article/7bc5521c5cdb46789acc784647028a7f

The article examines the research issues of studying sub-ethnic groups of the Tuvans, We proceed from the fact that the ethnic structure of the Tuvans is complex, and this complexity is due to the intricate ethnic and political history of the region. Problems of sub-ethnic differentiation and local ethnic groups as constituent parts of larger ethnicities have been debated in Russian ethnography and ethnology for a number of decades. Various interpretations of the term ‘sub-ethnic group’ have been suggested. We will construe it as a unity of people within a compact territory who view themselves as an organic part of their ethnicity, but recognize their difference from the rest of this ethnicity and have specific cultural features. A review of existing body of research on sub-ethnic groups of the Tuvan has revealed that there is no consensus on how many such groups exist within the Tuvan nation, or even which of these should be considered sub-ethnic. Soviet-time studies originally focused on consolidated Tuvan nation, but since the 1950s Tojin Tuvans have been studied as a separate sub-ethnicity. Meanwhile, Tuvans living outside the USSR were studied by foreign scholars. In the post-Soviet years, the issue of sub-ethnicities has been revitalized. Russian and Mongolian scholars have created a whole new ‘Southern’ direction in the study of Tuvan sub-ethnic groups in Mongolia and China. The ‘Northern’ direction is pursued less actively, with a body of Usinsk Tuvans living in the basin of the Us river in Krasnoyarskii Krai. Tojin Tuvans have attracted the attention primarily of foreign anthropologists as an indigenous minority. In the article, we focus on a number of research problems. The taxonomic units in the study of the sub-ethnicities have not received ample theoretical foundation. Various sub-ethnic groups have got unequal attention from scholars. There is a pronounced absence of comparative studies, and the information of Mongolian Tuvans is still fragmentary. It is unproductive to study ethnographic and ...