The effectiveness of livestock protection measures against wolves (Canis lupus) and implications for their co-existence with humans

• Published in: Global Ecology and Conservation
• Main Authors: Antonia Bruns, Matthias Waltert, Igor Khorozyan
• Format: Article in Journal/Newspaper
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier 2020
• Subjects: Ecology; QH540-549.5; Canis lupus
• Online Access: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gecco.2019.e00868; https://doaj.org/article/14f509656e084c23bb0464d16a24b56d

Wolves (Canis lupus) can kill domestic livestock resulting in intense conflicts with humans. Damage to livestock should be reduced to facilitate human-wolf coexistence and ensure positive outcomes of conservation efforts. Current knowledge on the effectiveness of livestock protection measures from wolves is limited and scattered in the literature. In this study, we compiled a dataset of 30 cases describing the application of 11 measures of protecting cattle and smaller livestock against wolves, estimated their effectiveness as a relative risk of damage, and identified the best measures for damage reduction. We found that: (1) lethal control and translocation were less effective than other measures, (2) deterrents, especially fladry which is a fence with ropes marked by hanging colored flags that sway in the wind and provide a visual warning signal, were more effective than guarding dogs; (3) deterrents, fencing, calving control and herding were very effective, but the last two measures included only one case each; and (4) protection of cattle was more effective than that of small stock (sheep and goats, or sheep only) and mixed cattle and small stock. In all of these cases, the relative risk of damage was reduced by 50–100%. Considering Germany as an example of a country with a recovering wolf population and escalating human-wolf conflicts, we suggest electric fences and electrified fladry as the most promising measures, which under suitable conditions can be accompanied by well-trained livestock guarding dogs, and the temporary use of deterrents during critical periods such as calving and lambing seasons. Further research in this field is of paramount importance to efficiently mitigate human-wolf conflicts. Keywords: Carnivore, Depredation, Efficiency, Germany, Intervention, Predator