Ideas and Perspectives: When ocean acidification experiments are not the same, reproducibility is not tested

• Main Authors: Williamson, Phillip, Pörtner, Hans-Otto, Widdicombe, Steve, Gattuso, Jean-Pierre
• Format: Text
• Language: English
• Published: 2020
• Subjects: Ocean acidification
• Online Access: https://doi.org/10.5194/bg-2020-394; https://bg.copernicus.org/preprints/bg-2020-394/

Can experimental studies on the impacts of ocean acidification be trusted? That question was raised in early 2020 when a high-profile paper failed to corroborate previously-observed impacts of high CO 2 on the behaviour of coral reef fish. New information on the methodologies used in the <q>replicated</q> studies now provides the explanation: the experimental conditions were substantially different. High sensitivity to test conditions is characteristic of ocean acidification research; such response variability shows that effects are complex, interacting with many other factors. Open-minded assessment of all research results, both negative and positive, remains the best way to develop process-based understanding of those responses. Whilst replication studies can provide valuable insights and challenges, they can unfortunately also be counter-productive to scientific advancement if carried out in a spirit of confrontation rather than collaboration.