Japan and 100 Years of Antarctic Legal Order: Any Lessons for the Arctic?

• Published in: The Yearbook of Polar Law Online
• Main Author: Shibata, Akiho
• Format: Article in Journal/Newspaper
• Language: unknown
• Published: Brill 2015
• Subjects: Arctic; Antarctic; The Antarctic; Antarc*; Yearbook of Polar Law
• Online Access: http://dx.doi.org/10.1163/2211-6427_002; https://brill.com/view/journals/yplo/7/1/article-p1_2.xml; https://data.brill.com/files/journals/22116427_007_01_s002_text.pdf

This paper examines whether core foundational principles can be distilled from the 100 years of history of the legal order-making in the polar regions. Despite differences in geo-physical, socio-historical, and legal circumstances conditioning the Antarctic and the Arctic regions, the examination of the processes of legal order-making in both polar regions demonstrates that there are some foundational principles being assessed and applied in designing their respective legal regimes. The identification of those core foundational principles would not necessarily lead to similar end products, nor would such examination necessarily advocate, for example, an Arctic Treaty System. This paper, instead, submits that between the Antarctic and the Arctic there are mutual learning processes already discernible at the foundational level of process legitimacy in international legal order-making. This examination also provides a broader framework to assess the existing literature that sees certain interactions between the two regimes at the level of substantive principles and rules.